Johnson, Terry. Worshipping with Calvin: Recovering the History Ministry and Worship of Reformed Protestantism. Evangelical Press: Grand Rapids, 2014.
There is significant talk these days of worship, but this talk generally centers on American pragmatism, a purpose/market-driven approach, and questions of socio-cultural preference. But what if the “worship wars” were nothing more than a trivial dispute over preference? And what if all this talk about worship, whether the “gospel” songs of the 60’s or the praise music of the 90’s are better suited for public worship, were equally fit for the rubbish dump? Terry Johnson blazes an accessible trail, for a popular audience, on this generally misunderstood issue of Christian worship. Johnson recognizes that that Christian theology is an integrated whole and that Christian worship flows from that theology. Worship reveals the state of our theology and practice. Historically, worship has also served a vital role in the defense of orthodoxy against heresy. This is especially the case for the Reformed branch of Christian worship.
“Don’t ever take a fence down until you know why it was put up.” Robert Frost
Worshipping with Calvin demands a concern for catholicity. The quote from Frost is pertinent to the reformation recovery of Christian worship. The reformation recovery of worship is not equivalent to the restorationist agenda. The church has had historic “fences” built up to state and defend orthodoxy, to mature the saints, to call the unconverted, etc. Instead, Reformation recovery meant the removal of medieval excess and a reordering or worship according to biblical principles. Quite the contrary to the restorationist, Reformed liturgists comb through Patristic and Reformation history, as well as through other Christian traditions, in order to maintain a greater unity. If we desire to amend historic Christian worship, then we need to look hard at why these extra-biblical practices were put into place. There is an irony at this point. Modern worship is rightly concerned to “reach” different groups, so it is often concerned with matters of cultural tastes, but this tendency may inadvertently destroy Christian unity. “Transculturality” is one of the great benefits of Reformed worship. Its music runs from the first centuries of Christianity and through what is best about the hymn movement in the 21st century. In this way, Reformed worship is best situated to maintain Christian unity and a multi-ethnic atmosphere.
Strengths: Johnson’s material on prayer was particularly good and I plan on referring to it again. His arguments for psalm singing were convincing. They were strengthened by his not taking an exclusive psalm singing position. Also, Johnson admirably demonstrated the order and simplicity of reformed worship.
Weaknesses: Johnson’s critique of modern worship shows up too frequently. While he offers many keen insights, the constant critique detracts from his overall goal. It would have been more beneficial to his project if he had used that space for a robustly biblical defense of reformed worship, and maybe some interaction with those otherwise reformed that Johnson takes issue with in several places. Additionally, I had expected to see more of Calvin on worship in this volume. Perhaps even an analysis of Calvin on each of the many vital points that Johnson addresses in this volume. Finally, while I found the discussion of the Lord’s Supper to be helpful, Johnson’s defense of Infant baptism leaves much to be desired.
One final word. Johnson quickly dismisses cultural contextualization. Reformed worship needs to take ethnodoxology seriously. The elements of Reformed worship ought to be present in all worship in all places. This does not mean, as Johnson seems to understand it, that Reformed worship can be air dropped anywhere around the world with little thought to the receiving culture. Johnson is right in his criticism but I wonder if there is not more to say on this topic. His treatment of emotion in worship also leaves much to be desired. While order is to be prized, Johnson makes emotion seem like adiaphora…take it or leave it. Aside from this final point, it is easy to recommend this volume on reformed worship.
Read More »
Right now I am reaching far back into the recesses of my brain for moments of inspiration. These inspirational moments are drawn from one of my favorite parts of T4G, the Band of Bloggers pre-conference.
Registration cost for Band of Bloggers is very low, usually around $30 and includes a sack lunch from Chick-fil-a. Each attendee receives a haul of book. This year it was 30 titles total! And of course, this pre-conference is held at Southern Seminary, so attendees have the pleasure of walking this historic and beautiful seminary campus.
Band of Bloggers meets in tandem with T4G. It is a gathering of those who are interested in what happens in the Christian blogosphere. At each meeting a panel discussion takes place. This year Collin Hansen, an editor for the Gospel Coalition web blog, moderated the discussion with panelists Justin Taylor, Trevin Wax, Joe Thorn, Denny Burk, and Tim Brister.
Here are seven reflections from this year’s Band of Bloggers.
1. Bloggers aren’t pixels; they’re people.
If you’ve ever had the pleasure of meeting any of the men on the panel, you would discover that they are kind and pious men, every one of them. Watching them on display, speaking with candor and enjoying hearty banter with one another, is a joy.
2. We further Jesus’s platform like John the Baptist or Paul did.
One of the early points out the gate that Trevin Wax made is that we should not try to learn from how Jesus built His platform. If so, we’d be innately self-serving, because that is precisely what Jesus does and should do. His greatest joy is to make much of Himself. Our greatest joy is to make much of Him. Thus, we should learn from John the Baptist or Paul’s example. We must decrease so that He might increase.
3. Christian bloggers should be qualified and tested voices.
The panelists didn’t go so far as to say that Christian bloggers should be called to ministry, but they should be able handlers of the Word and qualified teachers. Anyone can start a blog and have a voice, but is that voice worthy of listeners. Readers should look at the qualifications of the blogger. Is the blogger theologically trained? Is the blogger a pastor or professor? Does the blogger have a reliable voice tested by time?
4. Blogs should be extensions of real life ministry with real life people.
Many of the bloggers on the panel explained how their blog started and continues as an extension of their ministry. Some of their key audience is their congregation or the classroom they influence in real life. If what is written in the digital world does not translate into help for the real world, then it fails the test of praxis. Theory must become practice.
5. Freedom and risk is attached to independent bloggers.
Independent bloggers have more freedom to speak to certain issues because they are not expected to represent an organization. This can be advantageous because independent bloggers have a freer voice. Sometimes this is the manner in which a blogger emerges out of anonymity. They give a timely word about a timely issue. They may even critique that which bloggers connected to an organization might wish to critique but have not the freedom to do so because of a tie to a tribe or organization.
Of course, with this freedom comes a lack of accountability. Independent bloggers should seek accountability with others who might hold them accountable for what they say.
6. Social media conscientiousness is important.
Possibly the most entertaining, used, and discussed bit from this years Band of Bloggers is spawned from Hansen’s last question directed to the panel. Should we ReTweet compliments? Justin Taylor brought this immediately into the arena of sin, by calling it just that. It is a manner of consciousness that should be addressed. It’s sin that must be put under the heel.
Too few of us think about these issues, whether one is a broadcaster, influencer, or participant. Our digital words have eternal consequences. Thank you Justin for bringing this to our attention.
7. Bloggers selflessly serve others with their writing.
This is something that implicitly came out of the panel discussion. These guys took a couple hours to share with others something they care about. They didn’t have to do this with their time. They did it to serve others.
For the most part, people, even the panelists, don’t earn a living blogging. It is actually a costly practice. For most, it serves as an outlet of thinking and an extension of ministry. They do this to edify others. Their aim is our holiness.
Before we callously troll around a blog and tear apart someone’s writing, we should consider why it is written. Bloggers write to help. Bloggers write to divide right from wrong, truth from error. Bloggers write to serve.
This message came across in every way in which the panelists postured their responses. They wanted to further a discussion and guide the course of a movement in a beneficial, healthy, and orderly fashion.
If you want to listen to the discussion between Trevin Wax, Justin Taylor, Dr. Denny Burk, Joe Thorn and Collin Hansen please go here: http://www.sbts.edu/resources/conferences/band-of-bloggers-panel-discussion/
Read More »
This is our weekly roundup of posts for 3/17/2014-3/22/2014. If you have any feedback on how we can serve you our readers better, I would appreciate it. Thank you for reading and allowing us to minister to you throughout this past week through these posts.
Church Series: I didn’t want to go to church anymore (but I was wrong) by Aaron Armstrong http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-i-didnt-want-to-go-to-church-anymore-but-i-was-wrong/
Church Series: The Church: Gospel, Worship, and Mission by Mathew Sims http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-the-church-gospel-worship-mission/
Church Series: Church Discipline and the Mercy of the Good Shepherd by Grant Castleberry http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-church-discipline-and-the-mercy-of-the-good-shepherd/
Church Series: The Bridge of Christ by Mike Boiling servantsofgrace.org/church-series-bride-christ/
4 Steps to Ensure You’ll Have No Local Church by Joey Cochran http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-four-steps-to-ensure-youll-have-no-local-church/
Church Series: Why You Need Your Local Church Every Week by Dan Darling http://servantsofgrace.org/why-you-need-your-local-church-every-week/
Sermon: Defiled Worship from Malachi 1:6-14 by Dave Jenkins http://servantsofgrace.org/2-defiledworshipsermon/
Read More »
This is our weekly roundup of posts for 3/10/2014-3/15/2014. If you have any feedback on how we can serve you our readers better, I would appreciate it. Thank you for reading and allowing us to minister to you throughout this past week through these posts.
Church Series: The Importance of Church Membership by Matthew Fretwell http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-the-importance-of-church-membership/
Church Series: Growing Together Towards Love and Good Deeds by Dave Jenkins http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-growing-together-towards-love-and-good-deeds/
Church Series: Why Your Spiritual Growth Matters to the Community by Dan Darling http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-why-your-spiritual-growth-matters-to-the-community
Church Series: What does it mean to “one another” in the New Testament? by Dave Jenkins http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-mean-one-another-new-testament/
Church Series: A Better Way to Discern by Dan Darling http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-a-better-way-to-discern/
Sermon: Mirror of this age from Malachi 1:1-5 by Dave Jenkins http://servantsofgrace.org/1-mirror-of-this-agesermon/
Read More »
This is our weekly roundup of posts for 3/3/2014-3/8/2014. If you have any feedback on how we can serve you our readers better, I would appreciate it. Thank you for reading and allowing us to minister to you throughout this past week through these posts.
Church Series: 5 Ways You Can Help Your Church by Dan Darling http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-5-ways-you-can-help-your-church/
Church Series: 7 Ways to Create a Reading Culture In Your Church by Mike Leake http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-7-ways-create-reading-culture-church/
Church Series: 5 Reasons We Should Gather in Local Churches by Dave Jenkins http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-5-reasons-gather-local-churches/
Church Series: The Best Way to Help your Church by Dan Darling http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-best-way-help-church/
Church Series: Why Going to Church on Sunday is An Act of War by Dan Darling http://servantsofgrace.org/church-series-why-going-to-church-on-sunday-is-an-act-of-war/
Sermon: A Benediction of Peace from Hebrews 13:20-25 by Dave Jenkins http://servantsofgrace.org/52-a-benediction-of-peacesermon/
Read More »
“Don’t let yourselves be disturbed. Trust in God and trust in me. In my Father’s house are many places to live. If there weren’t, I would have told you; because I am going there to prepare a place for you. Since I am going and preparing a place for you, I will return to take you with me; so that where I am, you may be also.” (John 14:1-3)
“Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth, for the old heaven and the old earth had passed away, and the sea was no longer there. Also I saw the holy city, New Yerushalayim, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared like a bride beautifully dressed for her husband. I heard a loud voice from the throne say, “See! God’s Sh’khinah is with mankind, and he will live with them. They will be his people, and he himself, God-with-them, will be their God.” (Revelation 21:1-3)
“I will put my tabernacle among you, and I will not reject you, but I will walk among you and be your God, and you will be my people.” (Leviticus 26:11-12)
In this post, we will take a look at the current and future fulfillment of Sukkot, the Feast of Tabernacles. This important feast is pregnant with meaning, specifically the divine plan of God to one day restore that which was impacted by sin, namely God tabernacling and dwelling with His people. Barney Kasdan wisely notes “All the Feasts of the Lord have their own particular lessons to teach. Yet, because of its latter day fulfillment, Sukkot seems to be the apex of all the other appointed times of God. The goal of God’s plan is ultimately the establishment of his kingdom on the earth.”
Read More »