⏱️ Estimated Reading Time: 4 min read
Contending for the Word Q&A
📅
True Repentance and the Danger of Emotionalism
By Dave Jenkins
Question: How can we tell the difference between emotional excitement and true repentance?
(2 Corinthians 7:10–11)
Introduction
Welcome back to Contending for the Word. As we have seen this month, true revival is both Word centered and Spirit driven. Yet one of the greatest confusions in our day is mistaking emotion for repentance. Feelings may accompany genuine revival, but emotion alone does not equal transformation.
Paul draws a vital distinction in 2 Corinthians 7:10–11:
“For godly grief produces a repentance that leads to salvation without regret, whereas worldly grief produces death.”
Not all sorrow over sin is saving. Worldly sorrow feels bad about consequences, godly sorrow grieves over offending a holy God. True revival begins when the heart turns from sin to Christ in faith and obedience, not when emotion runs high, but when grace runs deep.
The Danger of Emotionalism
Emotions are a gift from God, but they can never be the foundation of faith. Throughout Scripture, people displayed great emotion without lasting repentance. Pharaoh, King Saul, and Judas all expressed regret, yet none were truly changed.
False revival often thrives on emotionalism. Music, atmosphere, and persuasive speech can stir feelings temporarily,
but they cannot create repentance. When emotion becomes the goal, people may mistake spiritual excitement for spiritual life.
The danger is subtle. An emotional experience can make people feel closer to God while leaving their hearts unchanged. True repentance is not a momentary feeling, it is a lifelong turning to Christ.
Godly Sorrow Produces True Repentance
Paul says godly sorrow produces repentance that leads to salvation. This kind of sorrow is the Spirit’s work in the heart. It is conviction that sees sin as rebellion against a gracious Savior. It hates sin not because of its consequences, but because it dishonors God.
When God grants repentance, the sinner does not just weep, he worships. He does not only feel regret, he forsakes sin. Biblical repentance bears fruit, humility, confession, and a changed life.
The Fruits of Repentance
In 2 Corinthians 7:11, Paul lists the evidence of true repentance, “earnestness, eagerness to clear yourselves, indignation, fear, longing, zeal, punishment.” These words describe hearts awakened by grace, people eager to make things right and live in holiness.
True revival produces that kind of fruit. It does not fade when the emotion passes, it deepens over time.
The person who has truly repented loves righteousness, hates sin, and clings to Christ for mercy.
Revival Affects the Will, Not Just the Emotions
Emotionalism seeks a feeling, revival seeks God. In revival, emotions are real but rightly ordered, they flow from the truth of Scripture and the conviction of the Spirit. When the heart is gripped by God’s holiness and grace, tears may fall, but they fall at the feet of Jesus.
Biblical repentance is not a temporary response, it is the evidence of new life. It changes how we think, feel, and live.
Revival that begins in emotion will fade, revival that begins in repentance will bear fruit for eternity.
Conclusion
True revival is never driven by emotional hype, it is born in brokenness over sin and leads to joyful obedience.
The difference is clear, emotionalism centers on the self, repentance centers on the Savior.
May we seek not fleeting feelings, but godly sorrow that produces lasting repentance and joy in Christ.
Only then will we know the deep and enduring renewal that the Spirit brings through His Word.
For more from Contending for the Word Q&A please visit our page at Servants of Grace or at our YouTube.



