Posted On July 25, 2016

Theology and the Mirror of Scripture: A Mere Evangelical Account (Kevin J. Vanhoozer & Daniel J. Treier)

by | Jul 25, 2016 | Theology, Featured

2016 has, to many, seemed to be the year in which the word “evangelical” has been completely watered down to nothingness. “Evangelical” has become a word that carries virtually no distinction and thus no meaning; everything from the media’s misuse of the word to the broadness of its use in churches have contributed to this. But rather than throw the word out, what if we simply need to recover its meaning? Vanhoozer and Treier won’t have the repudiating of this word on the basis of what it has socially become. Instead, they seek to hold onto it because of what  it means about the gospel (11). The goal of the book is simple. “Part one sketches an agenda for evangelical theology…part two analyzes in greater detail how that agenda applies to the evangelical theology currently being practiced” (41).

In the opening chapter, Vanhoozer and Treier set out to try to begin by coming to a consensus on how we should think about defining and identifying what “evangelical theology” itself is. They build their argument on an understanding of evangelical theology as an “anchored set.” This idea of an anchor is a wonderful word-picture for the discussion. Anchors, of course, are an immovable weight, a tool that prides itself on sturdiness. But the anchor’s primary function is to help the boat from moving. The anchored set of theology, then, should be defined “not only by its anchor but by the limited range of motion.” This is what Paul was describing when urging the Church to not be carried about by winds of doctrine. Vanhoozer and Treier go on to show that the gospel events are rooted in the very being of God (81). Chapter 2 turns its focus towards how Scripture plays the role of mirror, that it carries authority, and helps us understand the differences between first-level, second-level, and third-level doctrines.

With a foundation laid, Chapters 3-6 grow a bit more focused in nature, as Vanhoozer and Treier go on to outline approaches to mere evangelical theology. One must look at it as the pursuit of communal wisdom and the exegesis of Scripture, and these are two particular themes expounded on heavily in this book. Most importantly, theology, as the authors show, is not simply for the purpose of heady scholarship. Theology affects our very ecclesiology, and this book makes a case for that.

Here are some of my favorite excerpts:

“At their wisest, then, theological interpreters stand with unveiled faces before the light of Scripture, soak it up and say what they see. Doctrine is not a dull and dry substitute for biblical discourse but a means of catching its light, and perhaps of seeing further into the mirror.” (105)

“The Christian life is not one of solitary confinement but of life together, in community; similarly, interpreting Scripture is not the prerogative of lone exegetical rangers but of the gathered church, a creature of the word and hence an interpretive community.” (111-112)

“Differences over the first level are fundamental, while at the second level they are church-dividing but acceptable within evangelical cooperation. Third-level variety is possible within ongoing, close congregational fellowship. The goal should be to avoid the collapse of first order doctrines and obsession or schism over third-order doctrines.” (209)

This is an excellent opening volume of InterVarsity Press’s “Studies in Christian Doctrine and Scripture” series, and I couldn’t be happier to commend it to you. Vanhoozer and Treier’s prolegomena of how we must approach evangelical theology, from definition to practice, is an excellent tool filled with tons of wisdom.

Related Posts

Our Immutable Guarantee

Our Immutable Guarantee

On today’s episode, a listener writes in and asks Dave, “What is divine immutability?” What You'll Hear on this Episode The Bible’s Teaching on the Immutability of God. The Immutability of God at Work in the Christian Life. Subscribing, sharing, and your feedback You...

Why Doing Theology Right Matters—for All Christians

Why Doing Theology Right Matters—for All Christians

You Are a Theologian The case can be made that every Christian is a theologian because every Christian has a theology, whether well thought out or not.1 After all, the word “theology” clearly has to do with God (theos, Greek for “God”), and since the third century at...

Caring for a Family Member With Memory Loss

Caring for a Family Member With Memory Loss

On today’s Equipping You in Grace show, Dave shares about his dad’s dementia and his mom’s Alzheimer’s and considers availing of the means of grace personally and at your local church, along with advice on caring for your family member with memory loss. What you'll...

Five Motivations to Pray

Five Motivations to Pray

For years, when I thought about prayer, I mostly felt guilty for lacking a robust prayer life—reading stories of great saints praying for two hours a day or more left me with a gnawing sense of defeat. I would often resolve to pray more. But the resolves didn’t last....

The Purpose of Hearing the Word and Personal Bible Reading

The Purpose of Hearing the Word and Personal Bible Reading

On today’s Warriors of Grace show, Dave discusses the importance of hearing the Word, why what we hear is a reflection of what we love, hearing the Word and discernment, and delighting in reading the Word. What You'll Hear On This Episode Hearing the Word. The...

Taming Our Scattered Minds

Taming Our Scattered Minds

Controlling our thoughts can be one of the most challenging things to do as a believer. Betty Price, a longtime professor at The Master's University, stops by to unpack what Scripture has to say about how women can daily find victory in this area.

0 Comments

Share11
Tweet
Email
Reddit
Share