What Is Emotionalism?

Emotionalism is the elevation of feelings above truth. In the context of worship, it means chasing experiences and emotional highs rather than centering worship on who God is and what He has revealed in His Word.
It’s not that emotion is wrong—far from it. God created us with emotions, and true worship should stir our hearts (Psalm 95:1–7).
But when emotion becomes the goal rather than the result of biblical worship, we’ve lost our way.

The Problem with Emotion-Driven Worship

Emotionalism confuses feelings with faithfulness. It teaches people to evaluate worship based on how moved they feel rather than how aligned it is with Scripture.
It subtly shifts our focus from God to ourselves: “Did I feel something?” becomes more important than “Did I worship in spirit and truth?” (John 4:24).

This mindset leaves believers chasing spiritual highs and unable to endure spiritual valleys. It weakens discernment, opens the door to doctrinal error,
and fuels performance-based worship rather than reverent awe before a holy God.

Biblical Worship Is Rooted in Truth

Worship begins with God, not us. Hebrews 12:28–29 calls us to offer “acceptable worship, with reverence and awe, for our God is a consuming fire.”
Biblical worship is grounded in the Word of God, fueled by the gospel, and aimed at glorifying Christ—not manipulating emotion or entertaining people.

The Psalms are rich with both truth and emotion. But notice the order: emotion flows from truth, not the other way around (Psalm 103:1–2).
When our worship is shaped by Scripture, our emotions are stirred rightly and submitted to the Lord.

Jonathan Edwards on True Affections

The great theologian Jonathan Edwards wrestled deeply with this tension in his classic work Religious Affections.
Edwards taught that true Christianity is not cold or lifeless—it engages the heart with holy affections. He urged believers to be stirred to the
highest degree of affection by the glory of God revealed in His Word.

But Edwards also warned against mistaking emotional excitement for genuine spirituality. The difference is that true affections arise from seeing and savoring the truth
and beauty of Christ, while false emotionalism feeds on external experiences detached from truth.

“True religion, in great part, consists in holy affections.”

— Jonathan Edwards, Religious Affections (1746)

In other words, the goal of worship is not to manufacture feelings, but to behold God in His Word so that the Spirit rightly inflames our hearts with love for Christ.

Real Dangers of Emotionalism

• Shallow faith: Emotions change, but truth doesn’t (Isaiah 40:8).
• False assurance: People may feel close to God but be far from Him (Matthew 15:8).
• Spiritual manipulation: Leaders may use music, lighting, or words to manufacture a response rather than faithfully teach truth (2 Corinthians 4:2).

What Biblical Worship Looks Like

• Christ-exalting: It exalts Christ, not the self (Colossians 3:16–17).
• Scripture-regulated: It is regulated by Scripture, not trends (1 Corinthians 14:33, 40).
• Whole-person engagement: It engages heart and mind together (Matthew 22:37).
• Formative and doctrinal: It shapes us in holiness and sound doctrine (Romans 12:1–2).

Final Thoughts

We should desire worship that stirs our affections—but only when those affections are stirred by truth. Emotion is a gift, not a god. The goal of worship is not to “feel something,”
but to behold Someone—Jesus Christ, crucified and risen.

Let’s guard against emotionalism by grounding our worship in Scripture, shaping our songs with sound doctrine, and lifting our hearts in reverent joy to the Lord who is worthy of all praise—whether we feel it or not.

For more from Contending for the Word Q&A please visit us at Servants of Grace or at our YouTube.